Welcome to Eaton's Fresh Pizza - Hickory Street
Eaton's Fresh Pizza - Hickory Street has carved a niche for itself in Fond du Lac, WI, thanks to its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Nestled at 196 N Hickory St, this charming pizzeria specializes in expertly crafted, take-and-bake pizzas that customers rave about. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff enhance the overall dining experience, making it a beloved spot for locals. Diners appreciate the rich, cheese-pulling perfection of their pizzas and the customizable options, including unique toppings like shrimp and black olives. With consistently fresh ingredients and a focus on community, Eaton's has become a staple for family pizza nights and casual gatherings alike.
-
196 N Hickory St, Fond du Lac, WI 54935, United States Hotline: +1 920-922-1230
Welcome to Eaton's Fresh Pizza - Hickory Street, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Fond du Lac, WI. Located at 196 N Hickory St, this establishment has carved out a reputation that resonates with locals and pizza enthusiasts alike. The charm of Eaton's lies not just in its delicious offerings but also in its commitment to quality and customer service.
When you step into Eaton's, the first thing that strikes you is the inviting atmosphere, coupled with a modern ordering system. Using their intuitive tablets, customers can customize their pizzas just the way they like them. This hands-on experience ensures your meal is tailored perfectly to your preferences. As one happy customer, Kristine Marie, noted, calling ahead and picking up a ready-made order makes dining here convenient and enjoyable.
- Quality Ingredients: The quality of the cheese here is frequently praised, with Angela Hobbs noting the extraordinary "cheese pull" that is simply irresistible. Each pizza is made with fresh ingredients, ensuring a delightful flavor bite after bite.
- Creative Combinations: For those looking to explore unique flavor profiles, the shrimp, black olives, and onion pizza option has received enthusiastic reviews. It's a testament to Eaton's ability to cater to diverse tastes.
- The Take-and-Bake Option: One of Eaton's most innovative features is their take-and-bake service. Customers are provided with pizzas crafted to perfection, which they can bake at home. As Garett Hayden shared, this makes for an enjoyable family pizza night without the fuss of restaurant dining.
This establishment is more than just a pizza place; it’s a community hub where customers have shared experiences for years. Jo Ann Guell voiced her loyalty to Eaton’s, emphasizing their consistency and high-quality products. Travis Langolf echoed similar sentiments, highlighting the made-to-order approach not just for pizzas but also for their subs.
The atmosphere at Hickory Street is not just welcoming but also deeply appreciative of its customers. Alex Griep's heartfelt gratitude for the staff’s willingness to accommodate him late in the evening showcases the commitment to service that sets Eaton's apart. It’s clear that the team goes above and beyond, making it a preferred choice for many.
For those who prioritize value, Eaton's offers remarkable pricing. You can enjoy a 12” sub paired with a refreshing 4-pack of Sprecher’s Root Beer for just $15, as noted by Alex Griep. The affordability combined with the quality makes this a go-to place for families and friends alike.
Whether you’re a pizza connoisseur or simply in the mood for a comforting meal, Eaton's Fresh Pizza - Hickory Street stands out as a premier destination. With decades of consistency, a variety of fresh ingredients, and an unwavering customer-centric approach, it’s no wonder this locale has garnered a dedicated following. Stop by and discover what makes Eaton's an essential part of Fond du Lac's culinary landscape.
Love that we can call ahead, walk in, and our order is ready!
Love the option of shrimp black olives onion. Cheese is amazing here always. Want good pizza cheese pull? This is it!
This is the best pizza! You have to cook it yourself, but it is worth it.
We've been getting their pizzas for many years. They are the best! Love the consistency and quality of the product and helpfulness of the staff. Keep up the good work!
Been visiting for years. Love it. Pizzas/subs made to order.
Cannot recommend the team on Hickory St. enough. I work until about an hour from when they close and they’re always happy to squeeze me in and make a fantastic sub sandwich for me. Quality is always the same, never had a sub that let me down from this location. Pricing is perfect! 12” sub and a 4-pack of Sprecher’s Root Beer for 15 is phenomenal. A huge shout out and thank you to everyone at Hickory St. for all the fantastic work you guys do and availability to always make a delicious sub for me. Only feedback I can give is to let me tip with a card. They all deserve it for the service they graciously provide.
This place is amazing. You order on their tablet (workers will help you if you need) them they make your pizza for you to take and bake at home. Last time I was there, I got 2 pizza and a wrap all for 40 bucks. They also sell pizza trays, soda, and a bunch of other stuff too that makes a family pizza night, movie night, or just dinner great!
Always great, had a sub and a few take out pizza's. If you like pizza, they are made fresh, delicious, and how you like em! I consider myself very picky when it comes to pizza, not many can pass my test.. These guys have, for many, many years.. I moved from Wisconsin in the past and even had them picked up and shipped to me! I love them.